Haunted by the memory of Walter Holderlin, a soldier he killed during World War I, French musician Paul Renard (Phillips Holmes) confesses to a priest (Frank Sheridan), who grants him absolution. Using the address on a letter he found on the dead man's body, Paul then travels to Germany to find his family.
As anti-French sentiment continues to permeate Germany, Dr. Holderlin (Lionel Barrymore) initially refuses to welcome Paul into his home, but changes his mind when his son's fiancée Elsa identifies him as the man who has been leaving flowers on Walter's grave. Rather than reveal the real connection between them, Paul tells the Holderlin family he was a friend of their son, who attended the same musical conservatory he did.
Although the hostile townspeople and local gossips disapprove, the Holderlins befriend Paul, who finds himself falling in love with Elsa (Nancy Carroll). When she shows Paul her former fiancé's bedroom, he becomes distraught and tells her the truth. She convinces him not to confess to Walter's parents, who have embraced him as their second son, and Paul agrees to forego easing his conscience and stays with his adopted family. Dr. Holderlin presents Walter's violin to Paul, who plays it while Elsa accompanies him on the piano.
The film's original title, The Man I Killed, was changed to The Fifth Commandment to avoid giving "wrong impressions in the minds of the public about the character of the story." It ultimately was released as Broken Lullaby.
铺垫太长，看完还是云里雾里。全员大情种，为了自己的家庭破坏别人的家庭——这不会就叫男人的担当吧？xs
2022013画面质感一分剧本加结尾一分，其他的都没有什么可说的了，末世放逐风格版的活埋
疫情下催生的低成本小制作，主题还是贪婪的人性外加恶有恶报的结局，ps男主真“单纯”用脚后跟想也知道那人会耗死他再回来8
前半让人感觉会有些深度，后半直接拉低一个档次。
纯真人的变化到自食其果，大胡子也没好下场，人为财死，鸟为食亡，很多细节没有，场景层次不是很好，但是可以一看
剧情太一般。没想到还能碰到24小时的不死神人，加颗星。
i can fuck zac efron all night long
看着太难受了，干燥，没水没食物，很不舒服的感觉。。
故事虽然比较简单，一个男人守着一块金子。我倒觉得他所表达的内容还是比较丰富的那种情绪以及决策的纠结是非常有层次感的，本来发现一堆金的两个人就必然产生矛盾，没有现场弄个你死我活，已经是一种故事的设定。带着一部分精子离开，还是等待着所谓的同伴一起来，将所有的金子带走去火流成为一个纠结的问题，直到最后我觉得他守住的只是自己的坚持。故事最后也不出所意料开车走的同伴其实就是在等着男主角自己的死亡而独占金子。应该这也是人性吧。
影片一半，就猜到同伴不会回来。男主的贪心，错过了几次求生的机会。
冷色调，摄影是优势，一种末日荒凉感围绕，但成本又太小了，故事格局也不大，内容量也无法支撑90分钟，所以节奏就只能拖沓，导致废戏堆叠，看一半大概知道结尾会怎么推进，弱肉强食的荒凉之地，凭善心是要吃大亏，贪婪之欲又会直接葬送生命，不深刻却也有触目惊心的时刻，伺机窥探的狼群，暗地观察的伙伴，兽性和人性在那一刻并无二致，因果轮回冥冥之中也早已有了安排。★★
虎头蛇尾，挺好一主题，退伍军人尤其是特种兵的问题，处理不好就是一大问题。最后草草收场。
把主角对金子贵过命的心态拍得太突出，超出常人对求生本能的正常反应。
本片的剧情真应了那句老话，典型要钱不要命的节奏，男主发现了一大块金子，却傻傻让同行那个居心叵测的黑心老板去找挖掘机来挖金子平分财富，这人不是缺心眼就是财迷了心窍，果然在经历了恶劣的自然环境和本地人的折磨后，还杀人灭口却最终死于非命，当然导演为了公平正义，让那个黑心老板也被土著干掉。人性的贪婪与险恶在本片中肉眼可见，抱着财富死去能有什么意义，有命挣没命花的选择还不简单吗?整个片子的化妆与场景布置不错，很好营造出了一个沧桑荒凉的末世废土环境，让男主的死更是披上了一层无奈可悲的色彩。男主出演很是拼啊，不但从头到尾装容脏兮兮，后半段受伤后的惨不忍睹更是可以媲美小李子的荒野猎人，不过本片的剧情相对简单，人性的剖析也是显而易见，90分钟这个片长还比较合理。
编剧差了点，里面几个转折牵强了些，其他都OK
影片像是《等待戈多》+《盖瑞》+《沙海漂流人》的揉杂，风格又类似《亡命雷区》+《生死之墙》，沙漠的残酷让人对一切都产生了幻觉，在任何极端的环境下，活下去就是最大的成功。成天卖肉扎克埃夫隆也到了想磨练演技冲击一波小金人的年纪了。
黄金比较软，用小刀，铁锹，锤子，花点时间，敲出来几块，分解搬运出去。
有些部分转折让人莫名其妙，一脸懵逼，最后也是匆匆收尾！
人为财死鸟为食亡，没有财也不想卑微的活着，两姐妹其实都没有坏心，所以最后金子该是她的
比较紧凑的小剧情片，内容厚度不够，给抖音号剪应该一两集就剪完了吧哈哈哈
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
